The US says it has a tool that predicts what will piss off China — I have so many questions
Angry about that nuclear strike? Blame the computer
How would the tool work?
The tool reportedly analyses data since early 2020 and assesses the impact of historical actions. It then predicts which future activities will upset China, up to four months in advance.
It’s hard to envision how such a system would work in practice. How is the training data validated? What information does it use to reach a decision? How is it built into the workflow of the military? Could such a system really provide accurate predictions?
We asked Peter Lee, Professor of Applied Ethics and the Director of Security and Risk Research at the University of Portsmouth, for his thoughts.
Professor Lee, whose research focuses on AI-enabled weapon systems, was dubious about the tool’s potential:
Lee points to the example of China’s actions on the last day of COP 26. Few people predicted that the nation would insist on rewording the final statement from an agreement to “phase out” the use of coal-burning power plants to just “phase down” those plants instead.
“At a stroke, it allowed itself to pretty much do anything with coal for 50 years,” he said. “The political maneuver worked because it was unpredictable and timed perfectly to give the whole conference no choice but to accede to the demand immediately or lose the final agreed statement entirely.”
Trusting some Magic Eight Ball to envision such moves seems optimistic at best, particularly if it’s only analyzing data from 2020 until today.
What would it be used for?
The software reportedly predicts responses to actions including arms sales, congressional visits to Taiwan, and US-backed military activity.
The official quoted by Reuters said demand for the tool was sparked by incidents such as China’s response to the US and Canada sending a warship through the Taiwan Strait in October.
The US surely didn’t need a “tool” to realize that this action would antagonize Beijing. Didn’t its throng of human analysts could predict this response?
Deputy Secretary of Defense Kathleen Hicks suggested the tool would play a supplementary role.
“With the spectrum of conflict and the challenge sets spanning down into the grey zone,” she said, per Reuters.
“What you see is the need to be looking at a far broader set of indicators, weaving that together and then understanding the threat interaction.”
I hope the US isn’t delegating its understanding of other nations to a machine — or letting AI determine military action. At best (or worst), I expect it would inform decisions taken by military bodies or civil leadership.
Why has the US announced its existence?
Tensions between the US and China are mounting. The nations are increasingly at odds over Taiwan, trade, technology, and governance. USSecretary of State Antony J. Blinken has described the relationship as “thebiggest geopolitical testof the 21st century.”
The unveiling of this tool adds another element to the discord. When military powers divulge a new system, it’s because they want their rivals to know about its existence.
According to Reuters, the Pentagon wants to move budget dollars toward a military that can deter China and Russia. The promotion of the predictive tool could form part of this strategy.
However, we can only speculate about the motivations behind disclosing the software. The US may hope to intimidate China with the tech, add a veneer of data-driven “objectivity” to its decisions, or shape a deception campaign. It would certainly provide a new approach toplausible deniability.
Whatever the intentions, the next time that the US incurs the wrath of China, questions will be asked. Did they ignore the software? Did it make inaccurate predictions? Did they choose the antagonistic action?
What could possibly go wrong?
Story byThomas Macaulay
Thomas is a senior reporter at TNW. He covers European tech, with a focus on AI, cybersecurity, and government policy.Thomas is a senior reporter at TNW. He covers European tech, with a focus on AI, cybersecurity, and government policy.
Get the TNW newsletter
Get the most important tech news in your inbox each week.
